Dateline: Spring/Fall 2026
Place: Toronto
Issue: How to punish Islamophobic vs Antisemitic incidents
This story is about two respected dentists, each with more than 30 years in the profession, and each with serious aspirations to be leaders in their field.
Dr Jonathan Mayer, a Toronto dentist for more than 30 years, decided to run for the position of president-elect at the Ontario Dental Association (ODA), a professional organization that represents almost all of Ontario’s dentists. Already a board director, Mayer wanted the top job. The problem was his many objectionable social media posts, reported to the ODA by fellow dentists and others such as the human rights focused National Congress of Canadian Muslims (NCCM). The posts, often on Facebook, were eventually found to be
“extremist, containing misinformation, alienating and offensive, divisive, contrary to the globally recognized facts acknowledged by the United Nations and other international authorities and ultimately having the effect of undermining the author’s neutrality and fairness in his professional capacity.”
Here are some examples of the content of Mayer’s posts,
- hateful anti-Muslim, rhetoric and posted articles that minimized Palestinian suffering
- offensive remarks in relation to anti-Palestinian racism and Islamophobia
- comparing the keffiyeh to a swastika
- that “Antizionist academics might as well be Nazis”
- the US ambassador to Israel’s post the erroneous statement, “a large and vocal segment of Muslims believe that their faith requires them to force non-believers to convert to Islam on threat of death.”
- that counter-demonstrators at a pro-Israel event were “scum”
- a cartoon of Albert Einstein, a keffiyeh in the background and a caption “Tea Towel syndrome. Einstein’s theory of Relative Stupidity.”
In February 2026, 817 dentist members of the ODA signed a petition – and more than 1,000 wrote individual letters – to demand the ODA remove Mayer. They also stipulated that the ODA
“prohibit him [Mayer] from volunteering or representing the ODA now or in the future.” The dentists accused Mayer of “… behaviour and language that are inconsistent with the standards of professionalism expected from an ODA leader.”
“Shockingly, out of 12,000 ODA dentists, the ODA has chosen a president whose neutrality, judgment and professionalism were called into question…”
Dr Nehal Al Tarhuni, London, Ont.
As one dentist wrote,
“Shockingly, out of 12,000 ODA dentists, the ODA has chosen a president whose neutrality, judgment and professionalism were called into question in the investigation findings,” … Dr Nehal Al Tarhuni, an adjunct clinical faculty member at Western University Dentistry.
In late February, the ODA commissioned an independent task force to investigate Mayer’s comments– especially those on social media. The task force report found his social media posts concerning. Nevertheless, the ODA recommended Mayer partake in ‘education, reflection and taking some restorative steps’ (including issuing an apology). The task force did not suggest removing him from his position, or barring him from running for election in May 2026.
How do you know the Tooth Fairy is a journalist? They’re always searching for the tooth.
In early May 2026, at the ODA’s Annual Spring Meeting, Mayer was re-elected as a board director. The board ratified him for the president-elect executive position. There was backlash at the meeting as scores of members objected to Mayer’s status because he displayed anti-Muslim and anti-Palestinian bias. But Jewish organizations including CIJA (Committee for Israel and Jewish Affairs), the Canadian Women Against Antisemitism (CWAA) whose 1200-signature petition called for him to be let off the hook, and the Jewish Medical Association of Ontario (JMAO), campaigned for Mayer to be absolved of wrongdoing.
By June, the ODA General Council had finally bent to the pressure by thousands of members, and removed Mayer from the board. This despite his apology and his acknowledgement that his posts were offensive, and “did not reflect ODA values”.
U of T Dean of Dentistry forced to resign
On February 25, 2026, Dr Anil Kishen, the Dean of the University of Toronto Faculty of of Dentistry was teaching a class to dental students. He is a Canada Research Chair, Tier 1, in Oral Health Nanomedicine, where he has been on the faculty for 17 years. Dr Kishen is a top dental researcher in Canada.
At his lecture, Kishen showed two cartoon slides to illustrate his points about the human immune system, and to highlight the effects of inflammation on dental tissue. Here are the two slides:


A second year dental student at the lecture complained to the pro-Israel group Jewish Medical Association of Ontario (JMAO– which I wrote about here). Within a day, someone in the JMAO had gone to top administrators at U of T to lodge a complaint of antisemitism against Kishen and demand he be removed as dean. Two days after Kishen gave the lecture (with the two cartoons), the university placed him on administrative leave pending the outcome of an investigation.
This despite that in the two days between his class and when he went on leave, he had already apologized to his class and to the faculty for the cartoons. He had also agreed his lecture “contained discriminatory imagery”. Kishen insisted, “I was not trying to make any political statements with these images … I condemn antisemitism and discrimination in all their forms.”
No matter, a spokesman B’nai Brith, one of the pro-Israel Troika that includes the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA) that posted on X,
“There is no excuse for the conduct of Dean Anil Kishen during a lecture at U of T’s Faculty of Dentistry. B’nai Brith Canada is reaching out to the University’s leadership to demand accountability and action. We will not allow tenure and academic freedom to excuse and justify this egregious abuse of authority.”
Over those two days, Trevor Young, U of T Vice-President and Provost wrote in a public statement,
“He [Kishen] has removed the images from his course materials and has apologized directly to his class and the broader Faculty. He has also committed to exercising greater diligence in reviewing course materials to support an inclusive and respectful learning environment for all, and to improving his understanding and awareness of antisemitism and other forms of discrimination.”
Still in a social media post, B’nai Brith, a pro-Israel lobby group posted,
“Our students deserve better and we will not rest until our campuses are safe and welcoming spaces conducive of the success of all.”
U of T started an investigation by external auditors into Dr Kishen and the two cartoons. The investigation’s report, never made public, claimed that Kishen did not aim to promote antisemitism, the community members (faculty and students) were divided on Kishen’s actions and his apology. According to U of T’s Trevor Young,
“Some community members accepted Dr. Kishen’s immediate apology, while others were deeply hurt by the use of the images.”
U of T Professor Ramy Elitzur called participants at the pro-Palestine encampment “terrorists”– he compared Jewish students who participated in the encampment to Nazis…
While the university acted quickly to get rid of Dean Kishen within two days of his showing the cartoons, there was no criticism or punishment levelled at a member of U of T’s Governing Council in June 2024 when he called Jewish students, who participated in the encampment at the university, Nazis. At the Governing Council meeting, Jewish accounting professor Ramy Elitzur, at the Rotman School of Management, called the student encampment protesters terrorists. The Varsity reported that Elitzur
“criticized the encampment by saying that U of T is where Equity, Diversity and Inclusivity (EDI) initiatives ‘became IED: improvised explosive device… the preferable weapons of terrorists.’ Elitzur also compared Jewish protesters at the encampment to Jewish people who served in Nazi Germany’s military.”
When challenged about Elitzur’s odious comments, a university spokesperson told The Varsity that U of T has a “high threshold” for speech and expression, including “speech and imagery that are uncomfortable and offensive to some.”
Let’s consider both the alleged crimes and compare the punishments of Dr Mayer and Dr Kishen. . .
Let’s get back and consider both the alleged crimes and the comparative punishments of Dr. Mayer and Dr. Kishen.
Their alleged crimes…
Dr. Mayer’s offence was clear: he actively and knowingly denigrated Muslims, Arabs and Palestinians, not once, but several times. He admitted as much when he was forced, at the risk of losing his status, to apologize.
Dr. Kishen’s offence was not so clear. To illustrate a lecture on dentistry, he used two cartoons that could possibly be construed as critical of Israel (and thus, in the eyes of some, antisemitic). He claims, perhaps disingenuously, to have had no idea that these cartoons were controversial, and certainly not antisemitic. Certainly neither of the cartoons contained disparagement of Jews as Jews.
Which of the two alleged offences is the more serious, and deserving of greater punishment? Unless you believe that criticism of Israeli policies and actions in a putative genocide is synonymous with hatred of Jews; unless you believe in a hierarchy of bigotry, where antisemitism carries a higher valence than all other forms, Dr. Mayer’s offence is clearly the more odious.
Now let’s compare the punishment for these misdeeds.
Their punishments
For wilfully maligning and directing hatred toward recognized religious/ethnic groups, Dr. Mayer loses, not the opportunity to continue practising dentistry, but the opportunity, for a time, to be the president of a voluntary association of his peers. He is also required to engage (in the words of the ODA investigation) in ‘education, reflection and taking some restorative steps’ to change his ways.
As for Dr. Kishen, he loses the prestigious position of Dean of one of the top university dental schools in Canada and the accompanying dishonour. He had to resign as dean, though he did not lose his faculty position or his research program/funding. However, he has not been allowed to return to the university for the last nine months and now must suffer the further humiliation of not being able to teach till the new academic year, 2027-28. The punishment of Kishen is one thing – but the greater purpose behind it is to send a message that silences anyone in the academy or professions who dares to – even inadvertently – criticize Israel. For more examples, see my newsletters here, here and here.
But Mayer’s many Islamophobic and APR (anti-Palestinian racism) postings on social media, his comparing the keffiyeh to the swastika and his calling anti-genocide academics Nazis—were treated as relatively minor. He was not removed from his profession and could maintain his dental practice and connections with the ODA. It was only when pressure came from the NCCM and hundreds of fellow dentists who signed a petition to have Mayer removed that the ODA barred him from elected office.
This double standard is firmly in place. Charges of antisemitism are amplified by very powerful backers including many Jewish establishment organizations such as CIJA, B’nai Brith, Friends of Simon Wiesenthal Center, Honest Reporting and “burner groups” like Canadian Women Against Antisemitism (CWAA), Stand With Us and One Global Voice that cheer on the reputational assassination of anyone who criticizes Israel. Their purpose is to sow terror since we know is that the charge of antisemitism is almost always used as a cover for criticism of Israel.